Walk north from Carl Schurz Park this month and the waterfront path does something confusing. It reopens, then it closes again, then it reopens, then farther north it closes for a reason that has nothing to do with the first closure. There are two separate repair jobs, run by different parties on different timelines, so a run or dog walk calls for planning around each closure separately.
The confusion is understandable. The whole stretch, officially the John Finley Walk south of 90th Street and the Bobby Wagner Walk north of it, reads as one continuous ribbon along the FDR Drive. It is not one project. It is a decade of patchwork funding hitting different sections at different speeds, and this fall the two active repair zones happen to be visible from the same afternoon walk.
The First Closure Is Almost Finished
The stretch between East 70th and East 78th Streets has been under active repair for months, funded through a partnership between the Hospital for Special Surgery and the city. HSS has been coordinating with NYC Parks and the Department of Transportation on the work, which follows an earlier $1.8 million renovation the hospital funded between East 70th and East 72nd Streets back in 2018. The current phase addresses a structural problem that has nothing to do with weather: the esplanade here sits on a roof deck built over the FDR Drive in the 1930s, and that deck has been failing in more than one spot. Crews are still remediating a sinkhole near the base of the East 78th Street ramp as part of this phase, a separate repair from an earlier sinkhole at East 74th Street that NYC Parks has already fixed.
By July 2026, the East 71st Street pedestrian bridge and the esplanade south of it were expected back open. The 78th Street bridge closed that same month to let crews finish the remaining structural work, with full completion of the 72nd to 78th Street segment targeted for October 2026, reopening in phases rather than all at once. As of early September, that means most of this stretch is walkable again, but the immediate area around the 78th Street bridge is still mid-repair, with the last piece expected to close out within the next several weeks.
This is the closure with an end date. It is a defined scope, a named funder, and a construction sequence that has been publicly tracked since work began.
The Second Closure Began in Late April, and No One Has Set a Timeline
Farther north, a different kind of problem prompted the closure. Our Town reported that a widening sinkhole between East 93rd and East 94th Streets forced the city to fence off a stretch of roughly seven blocks with almost no notice. Parks Department crews put up signage on April 23, and the city sent a Notify NYC alert the same day. Unlike the HSS-funded work to the south, this section had no active construction crew standing by. The sinkhole had reportedly been visible for years before it forced a closure, described by advocates with Friends of the East River Esplanade as the kind of crack that had long looked like it could drop a pedestrian straight into the river.
This section sits at the southern edge of a much larger, much slower-moving project: the proposed $294 million reconstruction of the Bobby Wagner Walk, running from the 90s up through the 107th Street Pier in East Harlem. The city first earmarked $75 million for that project back in 2019. The Economic Development Corporation presented a formal plan in 2022. Construction was originally supposed to start in early 2025. As of last year's reporting, the new groundbreaking target had slipped again, to sometime in winter 2026.
That timeline matters here for one reason: the April sinkhole closure is not going to resolve on its own schedule. It sits inside the footprint of a project that has already missed two start dates. Barring an emergency city intervention outside the larger plan, a resident should expect this stretch to stay closed longer than the HSS-funded section to the south, because it is waiting on a much bigger and much slower-moving piece of infrastructure to actually break ground.
Two Closures, Two Timelines
| Segment | What Happened | Who's Fixing It | Status as of September 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| East 71st–78th Streets | Failing 1930s roof deck; sinkhole near the 78th St ramp still being remediated (a separate, earlier sinkhole at 74th St is already fixed) | Hospital for Special Surgery, with NYC Parks and DOT | Mostly reopened; final phase around the 78th St bridge targeted for completion by October 2026 |
| East 93rd–94th Streets | Widening sinkhole; roughly seven-block closure began April 23, 2026 | NYC Parks and DOT, tied to the larger $294M Bobby Wagner Walk plan | Still closed; no detour finalized, no fix expected until the larger project breaks ground, targeted for winter 2026 |
Read side by side, the pattern is clear. One closure has a funder, a crew, and a completion date measured in weeks. The other has an emergency fence, an advocacy group pushing for action, and a fix that depends on a $294 million capital project that has already slipped its start date twice.
What This Actually Changes for a Fall Walk
If you live near Carl Schurz Park and use the esplanade daily, the practical difference between these two closures is what you plan around:
- South of 90th Street, the path is close to whole again. Expect the last bottleneck around East 78th Street to clear by October, with the rest of the segment already passable.
- North of 90th Street, plan for a longer detour. The 93rd to 94th Street closure has no announced end date, and it is tied to a project timeline that has already moved twice.
- If you run or bike the full stretch, the East 37th to 60th Street gap near the United Nations was already a known break in the greenway before either of this year's closures, so this isn't the first detour regular users have had to build into a route.
None of this changes what makes Carl Schurz Park itself worth the walk. The two dog runs are unaffected by either closure. The views north toward the Roosevelt Island Lighthouse and south toward Gracie Mansion are still the same reason people have been walking this stretch since the path was named for John Finley, a City College president known for walking the perimeter of Manhattan, back in 1940. The path underneath that view is just having a harder year than usual, in two places, for two unrelated reasons, on two schedules that have nothing to do with each other.
If you're weighing what a Carl Schurz Park-adjacent address is actually worth this fall, waterfront access included, The Christina Kremidas Team can walk you through it block by block. Request a Home Valuation and we'll factor in exactly what's finished, what's still fenced off, and what that means for your building's value on the water side of York Avenue.